Psychic Pie Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Psychic Pie, a unique pizza haven nestled in the heart of Sebastopol, CA. Specializing in deliciously thick slices of sourdough, multigrain pizza, this casual eatery captivates taste buds with a menu rich in flavors and fresh, local ingredients. Each square and slice is crafted with care, offering options like the heavenly Fun Guy pizza topped with gourmet mushrooms and ricotta, or the aromatic Pepperoni, bursting with quality pepperoni and mozzarella.

In addition to pizza, the menu features a standout Kale Caesar Salad and delightful cookies that perfect your meal. With the ability to enjoy your slices hot or cold for take-and-bake, Psychic Pie makes it convenient for any pizza lover. Whether dining in with friends on their outdoor patio or taking a slice home, every bite guarantees a delightful experience. Don't miss out—this is a place destined to become your new favorite!

Pizza!

Mushroom Square (20cm X 20cm)

Fun guy square, organic, sourdough, multigrain pizza crust. Whipped double 8 dairy ricotta. Fidel's gourmet crimini and shiitake mushrooms. Far West fungi maitake mushrooms. Laura Chanel chevre. Finished with olive oil, sea salt, parsley and lemon zest. A square is simply a double slice. One slice per person is a good sized meal. Our pizza is much thicker than NY slices. If you are really hungry, grab two slices! Nothings wrong with leftover pizza. Consider adding our delicious kale salad. order online and select whether you would like slices hot, or cold for take n' bake. Take-and-bake slices come with all finisher toppings on the side to finish the slice at home.

$22.00

Mushroom Slice (10cm X 20cm)

Fun guy slice, organic, sourdough, multigrain pizza crust. Whipped double 8 dairy ricotta.Fidel's gourmet crimini and shiitake mushrooms. Far West fungi maitake mushrooms. Laura Chanel chevre. Finished with olive oil, sea salt, parsley and lemon zest. One slice per person is a good size meal. Our pizza is much thicker than NY slices. If you are really hungry, grab two slices! Nothings wrong with leftover pizza. Consider adding our delicious kale salad. order online and select whether you would like slices hot, or cold for take n' bake. Take-and-bake slices come with all finisher toppings on the side to finish the slice at home.

$11.00

Pepperoni Square (20cm X 20cm)

Pep pep square, organic, sourdough, multigrain pizza crust. Bianco di Napoli tomato sauce. Double 8 dairy fresh mozzarella and aged mozzarella. A generous helping Zoe's meats nitrate/nitrite free pepperoni. Finished with Valley Ford Creamery's estero gold reserve. Squares are basically double slices. One slice per person is a good size meal. Our pizza is much thicker than NY slices. If you are really hungry, grab two slices! Nothings wrong with leftover pizza. Consider adding our delicious kale salad. order online and select whether you would like slices hot, or cold for take n' bake. Take-and-bake slices come with all finisher toppings on the side to finish the slice at home.

$24.00

Pepperoni Slice (10cm X 20cm)

Pep pep slice, organic, sourdough, multigrain pizza crust. Bianco di Napoli tomato sauce. Double 8 dairy fresh mozzarella and aged mozzarella. A generous helping Zoe's meats nitrate/nitrite free pepperoni. Finished with Valley Ford Creamery's estero gold reserve. One slice per person is a good size meal. Our pizza is much thicker than NY slices. If you are really hungry, grab two slices! Nothings wrong with leftover pizza. Consider adding our delicious kale salad. order online and select whether you would like slices hot, or cold for take n' bake. Take-and-bake slices come with all finisher toppings on the side to finish the slice at home.

$12.00

Sausage and Pickled Onion Square (20cm X 20cm)

Sausage and pickled onion square, organic, sourdough, multigrain pizza crust. Bianco di Napoli tomato sauce. Double 8 dairy fresh mozzarella and aged mozzarella. Italian seasoned Sonoma county meat company ground pork shoulder. Pickled blush onions. Finished with Valley Ford Creamery's estero gold reserve. Squares are simply 2x slices. One slice per person is a good size meal. Our pizza is much thicker than NY slices. If you are really hungry, grab two slices! Nothings wrong with leftover pizza. Consider adding our delicious kale salad. order online and select whether you would like slices hot, or cold for take n' bake. Take-and-bake slices come with all finisher toppings on the side to finish the slice at home.

$24.00

Sausage and Pickled Onion Slice (10cm X 20cm)

Sausage and pickled onion slice, organic, sourdough, multigrain pizza crust. Bianco di Napoli tomato sauce. Double 8 dairy fresh mozzarella and aged mozzarella. Italian seasoned Sonoma county meat company ground pork shoulder. Pickled blush onions. Finished with Valley Ford Creamery's estero gold reserve. One slice per person is a good size meal. Our pizza is much thicker than NY slices. If you are really hungry, grab two slices! Nothings wrong with leftover pizza. Consider adding our delicious kale salad. order online and select whether you would like slices hot, or cold for take n' bake. Take-and-bake slices come with all finisher toppings on the side to finish the slice at home.

$12.00

Four Cheese Square (20cm X 20cm)

Four cheese square, organic, sourdough, multigrain pizza crust. Whipped double 8 dairy ricotta. Double 8 dairy fresh mozzarella, and aged mozzarella. Stripes of Bianco di Napoli tomato sauce on top. Finished with Valley Ford Creamery's estero gold reserve. Squares are just double slices. One slice per person is a good size meal. Our pizza is much thicker than NY slices. If you are really hungry, grab two slices! Nothings wrong with leftover pizza. Consider adding our delicious kale salad. order online and select whether you would like slices hot, or cold for take n' bake. Take and bake slices come with all finisher toppings on the side to finish the slice at home.

$22.00

Four Cheese Slice (10cm X 20cm)

Four cheese slice, organic, sourdough, multigrain pizza crust. Whipped double 8 dairy ricotta. Double 8 dairy fresh mozzarella, and aged mozzarella. Stripes of Bianco di Napoli tomato sauce on top. Finished with Valley Ford Creamery's estero gold reserve. One slice per person is a good size meal. Our pizza is much thicker than NY slices. If you are really hungry, grab two slices! Nothings wrong with leftover pizza. Consider adding our delicious kale salad. order online and select whether you would like slices hot, or cold for take n' bake. Take-and-bake slices come with all finisher toppings on the side to finish the slice at home.

$11.00

Oso Rosso Square (20cm X 20 Cm)

Gluten, translation missing: en_us.tags.milk, vegan, vegetarian. Classic red square, organic, sourdough, multigrain pizza crust. Bianco di Napoli tomato sauce. Fresh garlic. Oregano. Black olives. Finished with olive oil and sea salt. Squares are just double slices. One slice per person is a good size meal. Our pizza is much thicker than NY slices. If you are really hungry, grab two slices! Nothings wrong with leftover pizza. Consider adding our delicious kale salad. order online and select whether you would like slices hot, or cold for take n' bake. Take-and-bake slices come with all finisher toppings on the side to finish the slice at home.

$18.00

Oso Rosso Slice (10cm X 20cm)

Gluten, translation missing: en_us.tags.milk, vegan. Contains pork. Classic red slice, organic, sourdough, multigrain pizza crust. Bianco di Napoli tomato sauce. Fresh garlic. Oregano. Black olives. Finished with olive oil and sea salt. one slice per person is a good size meal. Our pizza is much thicker than NY slices. If you are really hungry, grab two slices! Nothings wrong with leftover pizza. Consider adding our delicious kale salad. order online and select whether you would like slices hot, or cold for take n' bake. Take-and-bake slices come with all finisher toppings on the side to finish the slice at home.

$9.00

Kale Caesar Salad

Mountain of kale massaged with our cheesy and zesty vegetarian dressing. Topped with pepitas, Sunflower seeds and estero gold reserve cheese.

$16.00

Chocolate Chunk, Malt and Salt Cookie

Damn good cookie. You'll want a second one.

$3.50

Peanut Butter and Miso Cookie

Peanut butter cookie on steroids. You will love it.

$3.50

Herby House Ranch Dipper

2oz of house ranch. Complete delight. Secret formula, no hidden valley shizz here.

$2.00

Spicy House Ranch

Spicy. 2oz of house ranch with Calabrian Chili's blended in. Complete delight. Secret formula, no hidden valley shizz here.

$3.00

Salads, Sides and Desserts